AR 623-3 — Appeals & Redress Procedures
Source: AR 623-3 (armypubs.army.mil)
NCOER Appeals
A substantive appeal challenges the accuracy or fairness of the ratings or comments. It requires new evidence or information not available at the time of the report.
An administrative appeal challenges errors in the processing or preparation of the report. Examples: wrong dates, incorrect rank, or missing signatures.
The Army Special Review Board (ASRB) reviews appeals of NCOERs. The ASRB can remove, correct, or transfer reports to the restricted file.
Substantive appeals must be submitted within 3 years of the ending date of the report. Administrative appeals have no time limit.
The burden of proof is on the appellant. The appellant must provide clear and convincing evidence that the report is inaccurate or unjust.
Redress Procedures
The first step in redress is to address the issue with the rating chain. The rated Soldier may request a correction through the chain of command.
The Inspector General (IG) investigates complaints of regulatory violations. The IG can recommend corrections to NCOERs that violate regulations.
The Army Board for Correction of Military Records (ABCMR) can correct errors and injustices in military records. It is the final administrative remedy.
A report transferred to the restricted file is not visible to promotion boards. Transfer to the restricted file is a form of relief for reports that are accurate but unjust.